Damn opposed, damn damn damn opposed.
I have been, and will continue to be, heavily against Occupy Melbourne. There are just too many unanswered questions for me, the whole thing seems to have been overrun by confused teenage anarchists, and i’m still not sure what they want.
Here are my reasons for being against the whole thing:
1. I’m still not sure what they’re yelling about.
These protesters have some good chants and slogans, but I haven’t heard one spokesperson for the event with the ability to make any sort of cohesive argument or justification for why they are there. In my opinion, a protest needs to have a specific grievance and a proposed solution. Occupy, in Australia at least, seems misguided and/or confused, which reduces it to illegal camping.
2. You’re claiming to speak on behalf of people without their consent.
The 99% thing I take offense to. Democracy is based on majority rules. If you really are the 99%, nominate some leaders and elect them to Parliament. Of course that won’t work, because in reality you don’t have the numbers. Real change is possible in this country, but you need majority support. The majority now see the movement as ‘them hippies that blocked my tram from taking me home’. Which leads me to…
3. Public support is necessary, and you blew it.
Despite the confused nature, I had no issue with Occupy until yesterday. The message all along was ‘we are here to send a message, but we will leave when we are asked’. Yesterday, you were asked, and you didn’t. The public, who you need to win power in a democracy, were confused and angry at you. Police were taken from their actual duties to supervise you, and you caused traffic chaos in a city which is gridlocked at the best of times.
4. Australia is a bloody good place to live.
You have some many opportunities to send a message, and make it as anti-government as you like. We have a free media market, allowing you to spread whatever ideas you feel. The police will work with you to ensure protests are safe and don’t inconvenience others. I’m still not quite sure why Occupy felt it had to go above and beyond what was reasonable?
All in all, this confused message was lost, the police and commuters (presumably part of your 99%) were the real losers out of this. The only appropriate thing to do is for the organisers to stand up and apologise for yesterday, lay low for a while and only come back when you have something useful to say.